PA Supreme Court Overturns Rule Of Capture Trespass Decision, But Allows Challenge Of Actual Trespass

On January 22, the PA Supreme Court issued an opinion overturning the April 2018 PA Superior Court ruling finding Southwestern Energy drilling company trespassed on the property of Susquehanna County landowners by taking natural gas from an adjacent property without permission through its unconventional drilling operations.

Southwestern Energy argued, and a lower court agreed, there was no trespass because of the “rule of capture.” 

Rule of capture means the first person to capture a natural resources owns that resource under English common law.  It can be applied to groundwater or natural resources like oil and gas.  Click Here for a Penn State Law presentation on the issue.

The PA Superior Court ruled prior cases involving the rule of capture do not apply to unconventional natural gas drilling because hydraulic fracturing is not the same as oil and natural gas freely migrating from a reservoir and across property lines.

The PA Supreme Court said, however,  “...(W)e reject as a matter of law the concept that the rule of capture is inapplicable to drilling and hydraulic fracturing that occurs entirely within the developer’s property solely because drainage of natural resources takes place as the direct or indirect result of hydraulic fracturing, or that such drainage stems from less “natural” means than conventional drainage.

“On the state of the present record, this alone does not establish that a physical intrusion into a neighboring property is necessary for such action to result in drainage from that property.

“The Superior Court panel appears to have assumed, if implicitly, that such

occurrences were impossible – but, again, there is no basis in the record for such an assumption.

“Thus, to the extent this lawsuit goes forward on Plaintiffs’ new, physical-intrusion theory, Plaintiffs will bear the burden of demonstrating that such an intrusion took place.

“In summary, the parties to the appeal are in agreement – and we concur as well – that the rule of capture remains extant in Pennsylvania, and developers who use hydraulic fracturing may rely on pressure differentials to drain oil and gas from under another’s property, at least in the absence of a physical invasion.

“The Superior Court panel erred to the extent it assumed that either (a) the use of hydraulic fracturing alters this rule, or (b) where hydraulic fracturing is utilized, such physical invasion is a necessary precondition in all cases for drainage to occur from underneath another property.

“More broadly, insofar as the panel’s decision may be construed to suggest that a natural-versus-artificially-induced-flow litmus should be employed to determine whether the rule of capture applies in a given situation, that standard rests on a false distinction and is disapproved.

Click Here for a copy of the opinionClick Here for concurring and dissenting opinion.

NewsClips:

See What You Missed Last Week: 350+ PA Environment & Energy NewsClips

Related Article - Rule Of Capture:

PA Supreme Court Agrees To Review Rule Of Capture Decision Saying Taking Natural Gas Without Permission Is Trespass

Related Articles - Natural Gas:

Act 13 Drilling Impact Fee Drops By $5,000/Unconventional Well For CY 2019 Saving Drillers $53.6 Million

EQB Approves Unconventional Oil & Gas Permit Fee Increase, Lower Sulfur Content Of Heating Oil Regulations

CFA Awards 4 Natural Gas Pipeline Service Extension Grants Totalling $2.3 Million In Chester, Monroe, Northampton Counties

PA, National Environmental Groups File Brief In Federal Court Challenging FERC Use Of Tolling Orders To Put Citizen Challenges To Actions In Legal Limbo

AG Shapiro Joins Other Attorneys General In Filing Brief Supporting Lancaster County Landowners In Challenge Of FERC Pipeline Tolling Order Process

Related Articles - Conventional Drilling:

195 Groups Oppose SB 790 Reducing Conventional Drilling Environmental Protections, House Set For Final Vote

Earthworks: Rolling Stone Article Links Oil & Gas Waste Radioactivity To Worker Cancers, Wastewater Trucks Operating Illegally

PEC, EDF: Senate Bill 790 Includes Dramatic Reductions In Health, Environmental Protections From Impacts Of Conventional Oil & Gas Drilling

DEP Oil & Gas Program Reported 94 Violations At 168 Conventional Well Facilities During 1 Week In April

DEP: Conventional Oil & Gas Well Violations More Than Triple Between 2015-2017

[Posted: January 22, 2010]


1/27/2020

Go To Preceding Article     Go To Next Article

Return to This PA Environment Digest's Main Page