On June 1, the Chesapeake Bay Foundation condemned the water quality permitting rule the Trump administration finalized as “an egregious assault” on states’ ability to protect waters within their borders.

The new EPA rule weakens states’ authority under section 401 of the Clean Water Act to ensure that projects to build natural gas pipelines, dams, and other infrastructure that require certain federal permits and licenses do not pollute state waterways.

The rule overturns states’ longstanding right to stop or place conditions on projects that threaten to harm local creeks, streams, and rivers, and shifts final decision-making authority from the states to the federal government.

It also arbitrarily limits how long states can review projects and restricts the potential damages, including the effects of climate change and air pollution, states can consider.  Air pollution from major infrastructure projects can harm water quality and public health.

CBF Vice President for Environmental Protection and Restoration Lisa Feldt made the following statement about the rule:

“This rule is an egregious assault on states’ longstanding authority to safeguard the quality of their own waters. Despite the Trump administration’s professed respect for ‘cooperative federalism,’ it is clearly willing to steamroll states’ rights and greenlight major construction projects with no regard for how they might damage state waters.

“By restricting the ability of the six watershed states and the District of Columbia to protect the 111,000 miles of creeks, streams that feed into the Chesapeake Bay, the administration is once again sabotaging their efforts to reduce pollution from nitrogen, phosphorus, and sediment to targeted amounts by the 2025 deadline.”

For more on Chesapeake Bay-related issues in Pennsylvania, visit the Chesapeake Bay Foundation-PA webpage.  Click Here to sign up for Pennsylvania updates (bottom of left column).  Click Here to support their work.

Also visit the Keystone 10 Million Trees Partnership to learn how you can help clean water grow on trees.

Delaware RiverKeeper Network

On June 2, Delaware RiverKeeper issued the following statement on changes made by the Trump Administration to EPA's Section 401 federal Clean Water Act certification--

On June 1, the Trump administration announced new rollbacks to Section 401 of the Clean Water Act, robbing states of their rights to deny Section 401 permits for projects like fracked gas pipelines.

This move will empower the Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) and other federal agencies to unilaterally decide whether or not a project should be allowed to advance regardless of the state’s determination regarding compliance with water quality standards and applicable state and federal law.

The move is part of the Trump administration’s efforts to fast-track pipeline approvals, using executive orders and regulation rollbacks to limit the power of the states that has been protected by Congress for nearly 50 years.

Section 401 requires a project applicant to seek a permit from the state if their project will discharge pollutants into water in that state.

Under the Clean Water Act, states have the authority to review and approve, condition, waive or deny a 401 certification. Section 401 ensures that states have a role in ensuring that federally-permitted/licensed projects, such as interstate natural gas pipelines, comply with state environmental standards.

Until now, a federal agency could not authorize a project such as a fracked gas pipeline until the state issued a 401 certification or waived their right to do so. The new rulemaking attempts to usurp this legislatively protected right of states; a right specifically protected by Congress in the Clean Water Act.

“This move is nothing more than a clear and obvious power grab designed to take from states their legal right to deny Section 401 certifications and to steal from Congress its role as the legislative arm of government,” said Maya van Rossum, the Delaware Riverkeeper and leader of the Delaware Riverkeeper Network. “The Clean Water Act and Section 401 are very clear about many things, including the balance of power between state and federal entities. This new rulemaking is nothing more than the Trump administration bending over backwards to accommodate the fossil fuel industry, and is an illegal and unconstitutional power grab designed to undermine states’ rights, state authority, state sovereignty, and the role of Congress as the lawmakers of our nation.” 

Many states have used their Section 401 authority to deny harmful projects in order to protect their communities and environment.

This new federal rule undermines the Clean Water Act’s cooperative federalism framework solely for the benefit of the shale gas industry, including companies seeking to construct and operate fracked gas pipelines, LNG export facilities, associated compressor stations and other related infrastructure.

There could now be significant gaps in water quality protection in states like New York, New Jersey, Pennsylvania, and West Virginia where there is significant pressure from the shale gas industry and pipeline companies to secure extensive shale gas infrastructure buildout.

The Delaware Riverkeeper Network plans to legally challenge the new rules.

Click Here to review a copy of the comments submitted by the Delaware RiverKeeper during the EPA comment period.

For more information on programs, initiatives, upcoming events and more, visit the Delaware RiverKeeper website.

Resource Link:

EPA Announcement: EPA Issues Final Rule That Helps Ensure U.S. Energy Security, Limits Misuse Of Clean Water Act

NewsClips:

Examiner: EPA Limits State Power To Veto Energy Projects, Setting Up Clash With Democratic Governors

The Hill: Trump Rule Limits States From Blocking Pipeline Projects

NYT: EPA Limits States’ Power To Oppose Pipelines, Other Energy Projects

Post: EPA Limits States, Tribes’ Ability to Protest Pipelines, Other Energy Projects

NRDC: EPA Curbs State, Tribal Authority To Block Projects That Harm Waterways

Related Articles:

Pennsylvania, Chesapeake Bay Foundation, Partners File Lawsuits Against EPA For Rolling Back Clean Car Standards

[Posted: June 1, 2020]

6/8/2020