Guest Essay: Oil & Gas Industry Waste And Radioactive Drinking Water In Pennsylvania

By Justin Nobel, Author of Petroleum-238: Big Oil's Dangerous Secret and the Grassroots Fight to Stop It

Since the fracking boom began in the early 2000s, oilfield waste has been spilled, spread, injected, dumped, and freely emitted across America, with particularly worrisome problems in Pennsylvania.

In 2019, the Pittsburgh Post-Gazette published an explosive story revealing a seemingly unusual number of Ewing sarcoma cases among youths in the heart of Southwest Pennsylvania’s oil and gas country.

While the Pennsylvania Department of Health has determined there is no “cancer cluster,” and no researcher has formally linked cases to the oil and gas industry, my reporting suggests the radioactivity brought to the surface by Pennsylvania’s oil and gas industry could potentially have played a role.

At the very least, radioactivity should be carefully assessed and tracked by epidemiologists to determine just how it may have influenced oil and gas country cancers like Ewing sarcoma, and industry and government officials should be investigated to determine if they had important knowledge or covered it up.

The radioactive element radium is brought to the surface in copious amounts in the oil and gas industry’s produced water. Radium is regarded as a “bone-seeker” because it has a chemical makeup similar to calcium and if accidentally inhaled or ingested tends to accumulate in bones.

Yet lax regulations, industry exemptions, and sloppy operating practices have enabled this radium to be discharged — sometimes illegally, often legally — into the same rivers Pennsylvanians draw their drinking water from. Pennsylvania Department of Environmental Protection data indicates radium levels in the state’s Marcellus formation can average 9,330 picocuries per liter (pCi/L) and be as high as 28,500.

For context, EPA’s safe drinking water limit for radium is 5 pCi/L, and at 60 pCi/L EPA formally defines a liquid waste stream as “radioactive.”

Some researchers have compared the concentration of Ewing sarcoma cases in southwestern Pennsylvania to hundreds of pennies being tossed in the air and some randomly landing together.

But the fact that according to the Pittsburgh Post-Gazette’s reporting six cases of Ewing sarcoma have been diagnosed within the same school district (Canon-McMillan in Washington County), including the pitcher and catcher from the same high school baseball team, should not inspire crass statements that duck a more rigorous scientific analysis, but legitimate on-the-ground research into contaminants introduced by the unconventional oil and gas industry, which has newly planted itself across the region.

The general scientific consensus is Ewing sarcoma has no known environmental causes, but important research from the 1990s links even minor increases in radium in drinking water to an increase in bone cancers, including Ewing sarcoma.

There is a “statistically significant” relationship between levels of radium in drinking water and Ewing sarcoma, wrote Dr. Murray Finkelstein, a Canadian epidemiologist, in his 1994 article in the Canadian Medical Association Journal.

I spoke to Finkelstein about Pennsylvania’s Ewing sarcoma cases for my book, Petroleum-238: Big Oil’s Dangerous Secret and the Grassroots Fight to Stop It, and he said to check radium levels in the area’s drinking water.

Pennsylvania American Water is the drinking water provider across parts of Washington County where Ewing sarcoma cases occurred, and spokesperson Gary Lobaugh told me: “All radium sampling results were non-detect between 2005 – 2019.”

But this is a deceptive statement, as EPA typically requires radium in drinking water be tested only once every nine years — in other words, a drinking water plant will sample for radium during a single moment of a single day once every 3,285 days, and significant public health decisions will stem from this value.

It turns out, drinking water treatment plants can concentrate considerable amounts of radioactivity as they filter water for drinking. This material builds up as a sludge called residuals.

An EPA report from 2005 says in areas with elevated natural radioactivity, or industries that may elevate levels, drinking water treatment residuals can be so radioactive they must be taken to special radioactive waste disposal facilities.

In Colorado, radioactive drinking water treatment plant residuals have been alleged to have caused cancer among plant workers.

However, I learned that in November 1996, Pennsylvania American Water was granted an exemption by the Pennsylvania Department of Environmental Protection to allow residuals from two of their southwestern Pennsylvania drinking water treatment plants (16,000 tons a year) to “no longer” be classified as “waste” and instead be reclassified “as soil,” to “be used as topsoil and in topsoil blends” in residential lawns, ball fields, highway projects, and landscaping activities.

My book reveals these never-before-published documents, and files I reviewed convey that nearly three decades later, this extraordinary exemption still stands.

While Gary Lobaugh, Government and External Affairs Director with Pennsylvania American Water, told me their residuals are “typically used for brownfield applications and soil amendments, and none has been used for ballfields,” neither his company or the Pennsylvania Department of Environmental Protection have been able to provide me with a list of the contractors who have handled and applied this material, or tests detailing its radium levels.

I grant credit to Pennsylvania’s academic community, who through cleverly designed research projects have found the oilfield’s radium accumulating in Pennsylvania creeks, reservoirs, and even the shells of freshwater mussels.

U.S. Geological Survey researchers in North Dakota tracked the oilfield’s radium 4.5 miles downstream from a spill site, where it built up in the floodplain at levels “significantly above the U.S. EPA action level.”

This research confirms that radium brought to the surface in oil and gas production can enter and become concentrated in the environment and food chains.

The Pennsylvania Attorney General must conduct an on-the-ground investigation, together with a thorough probe of Pennsylvania Department of Environmental Protection and industry files, to determine if the unconventional oil and gas industry’s radioactivity has also been enabled to accumulate in the bones of children.

Pennsylvanians deserve this.

Until it comes, myself — and many others trying to advocate for public health — will continue to feel like we are living in the Twilight Zone, where industry and government have aligned to make dangerous waste suddenly disappear, by magically transforming it into a consumer product.

Justin Nobel, Author of Petroleum-238: Big Oil's Dangerous Secret and the Grassroots Fight to Stop It.

Related Articles - Oil & Gas Waste Radioactivity:

-- New Penn State Study Shows Continuous Radioactive Radium Exposure From Oil & Gas Wastewater Poses A Threat To Aquatic, Human Health As It Accumulates In Aquatic Species   [PaEN]

Resource Links:

-- Penn State: Fracking Wastewater Accumulation Found In Freshwater Mussel Shells  [PaEN]

-- DEP: Potential For Environmental Impacts From Spills Or Leaks Of Radioactive Oil & Gas Waste Materials Is Real; Health Dept. Not Aware Of All Chemicals In Oil & Gas Wastewater Making Risk Assessment Difficult  [PaEN]

-- Shale Gas & Public Health Conference: We've Got Enough Compelling Evidence To Enact Health Protective Policies For Families Now  [PaEN]

-- PA Oil & Gas Weekly Compliance Dashboard - June 24 to 30 - Radiation Levels Prompt Shale Gas Wastewater Tank Decontamination; Replugging Conventional, Shale Gas Wells  [PaEN]

-- DEP Reports Shale Gas Operations Sent Over 138,000 Cubic Feet Of Radioactive TENORM Waste To Low-Level Radioactive Waste Facilities For Disposal In 2022 - Over 911,000 Cubic Feet Since 2017   [PaEN]

-- Republican Rep. Krupa Introduces HB 1656 To Ban Oil, Gas Wastewater Injection Wells To Protect The Public From Radioactive, Toxic Materials  [PaEN]

-- DEP Issued Air Quality Permit For Leachate Evaporation System At Westmoreland Landfill With Special Radiation Monitoring Due To The Disposal Of Shale Gas Drilling Waste   [PaEN]

-- DEP Releases Final Guidance On Handling Radioactive Waste From Unconventional Shale Gas Drilling Operations   [PaEN]

-- Liberty Twp., Citizens Group Appeal EHB Decision On Permit For Tri-County Landfill In Mercer County Over Threats Posed By Birds, Radioactive Oil & Gas Waste   [PaEN]

-- EPA, West Virginia Officials Working To Secure Fairmount Oil & Gas Wastewater Processing Facility To Prevent Release Of Radioactive, Hazardous Materials   [PaEN]

-- Earthworks: Rolling Stone Article Links Oil & Gas Waste Radioactivity To Worker Cancers, Wastewater Trucks Operating Illegally   [PaEN]

-- State Dept. Of Health Apologizes For Not Listening To Communities Suffering Health Impacts From Shale Gas Development; New Health Study Results ‘Just The Tip Of The Iceberg’  [PaEN]

-- University Of Pittsburgh School Of Public Health Studies Find Shale Gas Wells Can Make Asthma Worse; Children Have An Increased Chance Of Developing Lymphoma Cancer; Slightly Lower Birth Weights  [PaEN]

PA Oil & Gas Industry Public Notice Dashboards:

-- PA Oil & Gas Weekly Compliance Dashboard - May 18 to 24 - 3 Abandoned, Plugged Shale Gas Wells Still Leaking Gas; 480 Abandoned Conventional Well NOVs  [PaEN]

-- PA Oil & Gas Industrial Facilities: Permit Notices, Opportunities To Comment - May 25 [PaEN]

-- DEP Posted 81 Pages Of Permit-Related Notices In May 25 PA Bulletin  [PaEN]

Related Articles This Week: - Gas

-- Gas Industry, Sen. Bartolotta Seek Legislation To Eliminate Environmental Hearing Board Appeals Of DEP Permits For Natural Gas Pipeline Facilities  [PaEN]

-- Damascus Citizens: Do You Live In An Oil & Gas Wastewater Disposal Facility? Public Roads In 84 Municipalities In PA, One County In NY Are Being Used As Disposal Areas For Wastewater  [PaEN]

-- DEP Issues Oil & Gas Wastewater Injection Well Permit To PA Well Development LLC In Young Twp., Jefferson County  [PaEN] 

-- DEP Invites Comments On Renewal Of Waste Transfer Permit For 5 Oil & Gas Wastewater Injection Wells Owned By Bear Lake Properties In Warren County  [PaEN] 

-- EPA Invites Comments On Draft Oil & Gas Wastewater Injection Well Permit Renewal For Seneca Resources Company, LLC In Elk County  [PaEN]

-- Susquehanna River Basin Commission June 13 Business Meeting To Consider Water Use Requests Including 7 Shale Gas Drilling Uses In Lycoming, Susquehanna, Tioga, Wyoming Counties  [PaEN]

-- Susquehanna River Basin Commission Approves 100 Shale Gas Well Pad Water Use General Permits In First 4 Months Of 2024  [PaEN]

-- Guest Essay: Oil & Gas Industry Waste And Radioactive Drinking Water In Pennsylvania -  By Justin Nobel, Author of Petroleum-238: Big Oil's Dangerous Secret and the Grassroots Fight to Stop It  [PaEN]

-- Pennsylvanians Realized $500+ Billion In Public Health Benefits By Eliminating Coal-Fired Power Plants, Switching To Natural Gas  [PaEN]

NewsClips This Week - Gas:

-- TribLive: Many West Deer Residents Calling For More Stringent Regulations On Shale Gas Drilling In Allegheny County

-- TribLive: Indiana Twp. Rezoning Would Accommodate Fracking Off Route 910 In Westmoreland County

-- TribLive: Natural Gas Well Fracking Plans On Hold In Indiana Twp. As Planning Commission Seeks Info; Residents Pack Meeting In Westmoreland

-- Williamsport Sun: Republican US Senate Candidate Says US Needs Energy Independence [Why Do PA Gas Drillers Want To Ship Gas To China?]

-- Williamsport Sun Editorial: We Need Long-Term Answers To Energy Needs; Pursuit Of More Renewable Energy Can Happen Currently With Production Of Oil & Gas

-- FracTracker Alliance: Not-So-Radical Transparency - An Ineffective And Unnecessary Partnership Between Pennsylvania Gov. Shapiro And The Shale Gas Company CNX

-- The Energy Age Blog: Federal Radioactive Oil & Gas Waste Exemption History

-- WHYY: Could PA’s Oil & Gas Wastewater Hold The Key To The Country’s Energy Transition?

-- PennLive: Here’s How PA Could Become A Huge Player In Lithium Mining [Oil & Gas Wastewater]

-- Meadville Tribune Guest Essay: Abandoned Conventional Well Plugging Grant Program Is Opportunity To Work Collaboratively With Oil & Gas Industry To Benefit The Environment - By Rep. Mandy Steele (D-Allegheny)  [Conventional Well Industry Paid $4,400 Into Well Plugging Fund So Far In 2024]

-- The Allegheny Front: Air Pollution Decreased, But Sill Causes Hundreds Of Deaths A Year In Allegheny County

-- MCall Guest Essay: Now We’re Cooking With Gas And Deadly Pollutants - By Bruce Wilson, Green Builder

-- SpotlightPA: Communities Fear Health, Environmental Harms As They Await More Info On Hydrogen Hub Projects

-- TribLive/Spotlight PA: Communities Fear Health, Environmental Harms As They Await More Info On Hydrogen Hub Projects

-- Capital & Main - Audrey Carleton: Is Hydrogen The Road To A Decarbonized Future Or Just Another Lifeline For Fossil Fuels

-- Citizens Voice Editorial: Protect Consumers From Energy Market Volatility By Reforming Utility-Rate Process [UGI Gas Increases]

-- Bloomberg: Natural Gas Prices Will Be Increasing Through 2025

-- YahooFinance: CEO Of Pittsburgh-Based EQT Natural Gas Warned Federal Regulations On Carbon Capture Could ‘Sabotage’ US Ability To Meet Power Needs

-- Reuters: Top US Gas Producer Chesapeake Energy Cuts Jobs

-- Pittsburgh Business Times: EQT Acquisition Of Equitrans Gas Pipeline Company Clears Antitrust Hurdle

-- Reuters: Promising Pipelines, Fracking, Ex-President Rakes In Millions At Texas Fundraisers

[Posted: May 22, 2024]


5/27/2024

Go To Preceding Article     Go To Next Article

Return to This PA Environment Digest's Main Page